Right to work checks: the £60,000 mistake hiding in your hiring

A friend of mine took on a weekend barista last summer. Lovely lad, started the Saturday, worked three shifts before anyone thought to ask about paperwork. No drama, no inspection, nobody knocked on the door.
But here's the thing. If that lad hadn't had the right to work in the UK, my friend would have been on the hook for up to £60,000. Not a typo. Per worker.
This is the obligation almost nobody talks about, and it lands the moment you hand someone an apron.
The penalty that quietly tripled
In February 2024 the Home Office tripled the civil penalty for employing someone who doesn't have the right to work in the UK. Its current code of practice on preventing illegal working, in force from 1 October 2026, keeps the same levels:
- First breach: up to £45,000 per illegal worker (it used to be £15,000)
- Repeat breach: up to £60,000 per illegal worker, if you're found to have done it again within three years (up from £20,000)
These are charged per worker. Hire two people without checking and the maths gets ugly very quickly.
And this isn't aimed at people knowingly breaking the law. The civil penalty exists precisely for employers who didn't check. You don't have to have done anything dodgy. You just have to have skipped a step.
The good news is the protection is genuinely simple. It's called a statutory excuse, and you earn it before the person ever starts.
The statutory excuse, in plain English
If you carry out a correct right to work check before employment begins, and you keep the evidence, you have what's called a statutory excuse. That means even if it later turns out the person didn't have the right to work, you're protected from the civil penalty.
Skip the check, or do it wrong, and you have no excuse. It's that binary.
So the whole game is: do one of three accepted checks, do it properly, do it on time, keep the proof. Let's go through the three.
The three ways to check
There is no fourth option. A glance at a passport while you're rushed off your feet does not count.
1. The manual document check
You look at the person's original documents (a British passport is the common one) in their presence, satisfy yourself they're genuine and that the photo and dates match the person in front of you, then take a clear copy and record the date you made the check.
It has to be the original, with the person there (in person or over a live video call while you hold the copies). A photocopy posted to you on its own does nothing.
2. The Home Office online check
For anyone with a digital immigration status (EU Settlement Scheme, most visa holders, and others) you use the online right to work service. They give you a share code, you enter it along with their date of birth, and you see their status straight from the Home Office.
For these workers the online check is usually the only valid route. An old physical card is not enough on its own.
3. Identity document validation technology (IDVT)
For British and Irish citizens with a valid passport, you can use a certified identity provider to verify the document digitally. They run the check using technology that authenticates the passport, and you keep their report. Handy if you're hiring remotely or want to take the eyeballing out of it.
What you actually need to keep
A check you can't prove is a check you didn't do. Keep:
- A clear copy of the documents, or the online check profile / IDVT report
- The date you made the check, written on it (this matters, because it proves you checked before they started)
- The records for the whole time they work for you, plus two years after they leave
One more piece people miss: if someone has time-limited permission to work (a visa with an end date), you have to do a follow-up check before that date. Diarise it the day you hire them. When their permission expires and you haven't rechecked, your statutory excuse expires with it.
A scrap of paper in a drawer is not a system. Keep each employee's check evidence and expiry dates alongside the rest of their file, with every follow-up date in a calendar that reminds you, so it never quietly slides past you.
The mistakes that catch cafés out
In hospitality the risk isn't usually the salaried manager whose paperwork went through HR. It's the casual end of the rota, where everything happens fast.
- Skipping checks for casual, weekend or seasonal staff. A three-week summer hire needs exactly the same check as a permanent one. If you're taking on extra hands for the busy months, build the check in before their first shift, not after.
- Checking after they've started. Once they've worked a single shift unchecked, you've already lost the statutory excuse for that period. The check has to come first.
- Forgetting the follow-up check. Time-limited permission runs out. If you don't recheck before it does, you're back to square one.
- Relying on a photocopy. A copy of a passport with no online check (where one was needed) and no record of the date is not a valid check.
From 1 October 2026 the duty reaches beyond employees. Section 48 of the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Act 2025 came into force on that date and extends right to work checks to worker's contracts, individual sub-contractors and people engaged through an online matching service. Casual and seasonal employees were always in scope; for a cafe, the new group is mainly the people you take on directly who are neither employees nor running their own business: casual staff on a worker's agreement rather than an employment contract, and the "self-employed" baker who works your hours to your spec, who is often self-employed in name only and a worker in law. The Weekly Grind of 31 August covers the commencement date and the latest Home Office enforcement data.
Correction, 5 October 2026: an earlier version of this paragraph listed the self-employed baker, the contractor who sends a substitute and a courier you engage directly as examples straight after listing the three new categories, individual sub-contractors among them. The Home Office's final guidance, published on 1 October, defines an individual sub-contractor by a chain of contracts, so a baker you engage directly for your own cafe is not one: they are in scope if they are on a worker's contract, and out of scope if they genuinely run their own business. The final guide also says buying cleaning from a firm or cover from an agency for your own business, rather than to fulfil a contract you have with someone else, does not make their staff your check, that arrangements entered into before 1 October are not caught retrospectively, and that a contract allowing someone to send a substitute can bring its own checks. The same paragraph previously said such people were often "your employees in law"; it now says "a worker in law", which is closer to the point, though the guide's own definition of a worker's contract is broader than the employment-law test and does not simply follow it. The Weekly Grind of 5 October covers the final guide.
Build it into onboarding and forget about it
The fix isn't to remember harder. It's to make the check a fixed step that has to happen before anyone is added to the rota, the same way you'd never let someone near the till without a quick handover.
A simple onboarding order that works:
- Verbal yes from the candidate
- Right to work check (one of the three above) and copy filed with the date
- Follow-up date diarised if their permission is time-limited
- Then contract or written statement of main terms, rota, apron
While you're setting up that checklist, it's worth costing the hire properly too. Our new hire calculator shows what someone really costs once you add the bits that don't appear on their hourly rate, and right to work compliance sits alongside the other duties that land the day you employ someone, like pension auto-enrolment. It's all part of the wider employment law picture every café operator is now working inside.
A right to work check takes about five minutes. The penalty for skipping it can take £60,000. That's the worst risk-to-effort ratio in your whole business, and it's entirely avoidable. Do the check, keep the proof, do it before day one. Every time.
Ed O'Brien has run Hunters Cake Company for 17 years across cafés in Witney, Burford, and a bakery in Carterton, Oxfordshire. He's building Brikly - modular tools that give independent café owners the same data the big chains have, without the big chain price tag.